SEO Health Score & Indexing Issue: Not All Fixes Are Needed

Last Updated: 1 Dec, 2023

Technical SEO is undeniably a cornerstone of effective SEO strategy. Issues like slow page load times, broken links, and crawl errors can significantly impact a site’s usability and ability to be indexed by search engines effectively. However, the approach to technical SEO needs to be pragmatic and prioritized.

SEO health scores from tools like SEMrush and Ahrefs, Screaming Frog SEO Spider, and Google Search Console’s indexing reports are invaluable in SEO audits. The common belief that the essence of SEO lies in meticulously fixing every error flagged by tools has been a narrative for years. But is this approach truly the key to unlocking a website’s traffic and conversion potential? 

Perfect SEO Health Scores: Does it Really Matter?

SEO tools quantify complex SEO factors into a single score. It’s tempting to think that a perfect score equates to SEO success. While these scores are helpful, they sometimes tell you what’s essential. For instance, addressing minor issues like missing alt tags might improve your score but won’t significantly impact your site’s overall performance. It’s like fixing a small scratch on a car’s paintwork when it needs an engine tune-up.

 If a tool flags a title for being just a few characters over an arbitrary ideal length — say, 61 characters instead of the recommended 60 — it’s not necessarily cause for alarm. Becoming obsessed with such minute details can be counterproductive. While it’s beneficial to adhere to general guidelines for optimization, it’s equally crucial to remember that a few extra characters in a title are unlikely to make or break your SEO efforts. The focus should remain on creating relevant, engaging, and accurately descriptive titles rather than fixating on adhering to a strict character limit.

If a page with a low word count might be flagged as a “thin content” issue. However, if this page is a contact form or a login page, its brevity is appropriate and doesn’t necessitate revision. Conversely, if a critical product page lacks sufficient content, this warrants more immediate attention as it directly impacts user engagement and search visibility.

Indexing Issues Sometimes May Not Be an Issues

The indexing issues reported in Google Search Console or other platforms are a prime example of an often misunderstood area. Not all pages on a website need to be indexed; in some cases, it’s better if they aren’t. Indexing URLs like login screens, certain administrative pages, redirected pages, decorative images, and CSS files don’t add value to search engine listings.

Google’s algorithms have become sophisticated enough to identify and ignore such content. So, when Google Search Console reports these pages as “Not Indexed,” it’s not necessarily a problem. It’s more an indication of Google’s understanding of your site’s content.

SEO isn’t about fixing every technical and indexing issue; it’s about setting the right things. This means focusing on issues that genuinely improve your site’s performance. For example, enhancing site speed or ensuring mobile-friendliness are critical tasks that significantly affect user experience and site ranking.

On the other hand, some flagged issues might have minimal impact. Investing time and resources in these can lead you down a rabbit hole, diverting attention from more impactful strategies.

The Context-Driven Approach to Technical SEO

Context is king in SEO. Not every issue flagged by a Technical SEO tool requires the same level of attention. It’s essential to evaluate these issues based on how they affect your website and its goals.

For instance, a small blog might be fine with a few technical glitches as much as a large e-commerce site would. Understanding what matters for your particular scenario is crucial in effective SEO decisions.

The key lies in distinguishing which issues will genuinely move the needle. This discernment requires an understanding that SEO is not just about technical optimization but also content relevance, user engagement, and overall site quality.

How to Implement a Context-Driven Technical SEO Approach

  1. Evaluate SEO Recommendations Based on Your Site’s Context: Assess how each issue aligns with your site’s goals before diving into fixes. For example, a small blog focused on niche content might not need to prioritize a minor image optimization as urgently as an e-commerce site would focus on streamlining its checkout process.
  2. Prioritize Issues Based on Impact: Identify which issues will significantly affect your site’s performance. This might mean prioritizing site speed and mobile responsiveness for an e-commerce platform, while a content-driven blog might focus more on keyword optimization and content quality.
  3. Understand the Role of Content and User Engagement: Recognize that SEO extends beyond technical fixes. For many sites, particularly those centered around content, improving your content’s relevance, quality, and engagement potential can be far more beneficial than addressing every minor technical issue.
  4. Implement Tailored Fixes: Once you’ve identified the most impactful issues, implement solutions tailored to your site’s needs. This might involve technical SEO work, content enhancements, and user experience improvements.
  5. Monitor and Adapt: SEO is not static. Regularly review your site’s performance, keeping an eye on how changes affect user behavior and search rankings. Be prepared to adapt your strategy in response to new data and evolving SEO best practices.
  6. Educate Yourself on SEO Trends and Best Practices: Stay informed about the latest developments in SEO. Understanding the current landscape will help you better evaluate the relevance and importance of the issues flagged by SEO tools.

SEO Tools as Guides, Not Absolute Authorities

SEO tools are best used as guides, not absolute authorities. They provide valuable insights but need help capturing your site’s unique aspects or specific needs. It’s important to interpret their findings critically, understanding that only some recommendations will benefit your site.

A balanced approach to SEO means using tools like SEMrush, Ahrefs, Screaming Frog SEO Spider, and Google Search Console as part of a broader strategy. SEO managers and consultants should focus on changes that enhance site performance and user experience rather than chasing a perfect score or obsessing over every minor issue. By understanding the nuances of SEO tools and prioritizing efforts based on your website’s specific needs, you can create a more effective, efficient SEO strategy that drives actual results.

🚀Look for a Content & SEO Specialist to Boost Your Website Traffic?


Read More